Former Letcher County Sheriff Shawn Stines’ Trial: Defense Claims Extreme Emotional Disturbance in Judge Kevin Mullins’ Shooting

Close-up of a smoking gun barrel.

Former Letcher County Sheriff Shawn Stines faces first-degree murder charges for allegedly shooting District Judge Kevin Mullins, as his defense attorney claims “extreme emotional disturbance” in a controversial strategy.

At a Glance

  • Shawn Stines, former Letcher County Sheriff, is charged with first-degree murder for shooting Judge Kevin Mullins on September 19, 2024.
  • Defense attorney Jeremy Bartley argues for a manslaughter charge, citing “extreme emotional disturbance.”
  • Surveillance footage of the shooting was presented in court as crucial evidence.
  • The case has been sent to a grand jury, with Stines facing potential capital punishment if convicted.
  • The incident occurred following a lunch meeting between Stines and Mullins, suggesting a personal connection to the case.

The Shooting and Immediate Aftermath

On September 19, 2024, the Letcher County Courthouse became the scene of a shocking tragedy when former Sheriff Shawn “Mickey” Stines allegedly shot and killed District Judge Kevin Mullins. The incident occurred following a lunch meeting between the two men, who were longtime friends and colleagues. Kentucky State Police Detective Clayton Stamper testified that Stines attempted to call his daughter using both his and Mullins’ phones before the shooting took place.

According to reports, multiple law enforcement agencies responded to the scene, where they found Judge Mullins with several gunshot wounds. Despite lifesaving measures, the judge could not be revived. Stines was arrested at the scene without incident and immediately charged with first-degree murder.

Legal Proceedings and Defense Strategy

In a preliminary hearing, Stines appeared in court wearing a jail uniform and handcuffs. Chief Regional Judge Rupert Wilhoit found sufficient evidence to send the case to a grand jury. The prosecution presented surveillance footage of the shooting as crucial evidence in the case.

“I was told that Judge made a statement to Mickey about, ‘Do we need to meet private in my chambers?’ That’s all I was told,” Stamper said.

Defense attorney Jeremy Bartley is pursuing a controversial strategy, arguing that Stines was under “extreme emotional disturbance” at the time of the shooting. This approach aims to reduce the charges from murder to manslaughter. Bartley’s argument suggests that the incident was not premeditated but rather a result of heightened emotional stress.

Potential Motives and Complexities

The motive behind the shooting remains unclear, but several factors have emerged that add layers of complexity to the case. Stines reportedly made cryptic statements after the shooting, claiming, “they’re trying to kidnap my wife and kid.” This statement has led to speculation about possible perceived threats or paranoia on Stines’ part.

Adding another layer of intrigue, it was revealed that Stines had recently given a deposition in a federal lawsuit involving allegations of sexual misconduct by a former deputy sheriff in Judge Mullins’ chambers. The connection between this lawsuit and the shooting, if any, remains to be determined.

Community Impact and Reactions

The shooting has sent shockwaves through the Letcher County community and beyond. Judge Mullins, appointed in 2009 and elected in 2010, was known for his innovative approaches to handling low-level drug offenses. His loss has been deeply felt by those who knew him and benefited from his work in the judicial system.

“His passion for people was his magic touch. He can’t begin to count the number of lives that he saved or improved.” Judge Debra Lambert said at the funeral.

Kentucky Governor Andy Beshear expressed sorrow over the incident, highlighting the broader issue of violence in society. The case has raised serious questions about the safety of judicial officials and the integrity of law enforcement in the region.

As the legal proceedings continue, the community remains in mourning, grappling with the loss of a respected judge and the shocking actions of a once-trusted law enforcement officer. The outcome of this case will likely have far-reaching implications for the local justice system and community trust in public officials.

Sources:

  1. Chilling Details Emerge About Ex-Kentucky Sheriff Accused of Killing Judge
  2. Kentucky sheriff killed judge in his chambers following an argument, police say. Here’s what we know
  3. Sheriff charged in killing of judge inside Kentucky courthouse, police say
  4. Lawyer for Sheriff Who Killed Judge Says It Wasn’t Planned, Will Use ‘Extreme Emotional Disturbance’ Defense
  5. Kentucky sheriff reportedly shoots judge: A look at the timeline, investigation
  6. Tiny Kentucky town is rocked as their sheriff is jailed in the killing of a prominent judge

RELATED ARTICLESMORE FROM AUTHOR